
I have always thought a library was worth visiting even when you have no particular book in mind. You might go in looking for a gardening guide and come out with a history of an old house, or pick up a novel because its title caught your eye. A good library allows for that sort of wandering. There is no purchase to make, no hurry to leave, and usually someone behind the desk who knows where to find what you need.
Some libraries have been welcoming readers for more than a century. Their shelves have seen generations come and go, and along with the books, they have accumulated stories of their own. A few of those stories concern people who, according to local legend, never quite left.
I went looking for five libraries with ghost stories that had actually been recorded. The libraries are real, and so are the accounts published about them. Whether the ghosts are another matter entirely.
Marsh’s Library, Dublin, Ireland
Marsh’s Library opened in 1707, and much of it still looks as a visitor from that century might remember. The old bookcases and narrow reading spaces are reason enough to visit. But one story attached to the library concerns its founder, Archbishop Narcissus Marsh.
According to a Dublin legend, Marsh was distressed when his niece ran away with a sea captain. Before she left, she supposedly hid a note asking his forgiveness inside one of the books. He searched for it without success. His ghost, the story goes, still moves among the shelves looking for that letter. I rather like that this haunting is not about a frightening apparition, but about a message someone desperately wanted to read.
Willard Library, Evansville, Indiana
Willard Library has served Evansville since 1885. Its most famous story began, according to the library’s own account, in 1937. A custodian tending the furnace in the basement reported seeing a woman in gray who disappeared.
She became known as the Grey Lady. Over the years, people have described footsteps, the scent of perfume, and books that seemed to move without help. The library has collected these reports rather than pretending to know exactly who the woman was. I suspect that after a while, librarians become accustomed to answering questions about a visitor who never checks out a book.
Peoria Public Library, Peoria, Illinois
Peoria’s library history reaches into the nineteenth century, and its ghost tales have followed it through changes in buildings. The American Library Association Archives has preserved accounts of unexplained voices, cold spots, and a figure some have associated with early library director E. S. Willcox.
The details belong to local legend, not established history. Still, I find it interesting that a story can stay with a library even when the rooms themselves change. People remember the books, the people who cared for them, and sometimes a mystery that no one has quite settled.
Cairo Public Library, Cairo, Illinois
The historic Cairo Public Library has a ghost with a rather ordinary name: Toby. Accounts gathered by the American Library Association Archives place the supposed activity around the Special Collections room. Witnesses have reported chairs creaking in empty spaces and small, unexplained lights among the shelves.
There is something fitting about a library ghost keeping close to Special Collections. If I were looking for the oldest and most interesting stories in a building, that is probably where I would go too.
Reid Memorial Library, Godfrey, Illinois
Reid Memorial Library occupies what was once a chapel at Monticello Seminary. Harriet Newell Haskell, who became head of the school in 1867, devoted decades to its students. Later stories associated her with the old chapel, including reports of a faint scent of lilacs and the feeling of someone gently touching a shoulder.
Those experiences cannot establish that Haskell remained there in spirit. They do tell us how fondly she was remembered. Of all the ghost stories connected to libraries, this one seems less interested in startling people than in keeping a beloved teacher close.
More Reasons to Open the Door
I cannot tell you whether any of these libraries truly has a ghost, but I can recommend visiting a library, especially one you have never been inside. Ask how old the building is. Look for a local history shelf. Find out whether it has an archive, a reading room, or an old photograph showing what the town once looked like.
Libraries do more than lend books. They keep a community’s memory within reach, and they give us room to discover something we did not know we were looking for. If you happen to hear a footstep in an empty aisle, well, perhaps there is one more story to ask the librarian about.
Just a bit of thinking this morning from the Uncommon Bookshop!
Sources and further reading
- Marsh’s Library: History and Dublin City Council: Haunted Dublin
- Willard Library: Ghost FAQs
- American Library Association Archives: Spooky Stacks (Peoria and Cairo)
- Reid Memorial Library: Historical accounts and reported encounters
The ghost stories above are published legends and reported experiences, not verified supernatural events.
Leave a Reply