Some bookstores become memorable because of their inventory. Some because of their owners. Some because they occupy a certain corner of a city at the right time and gather enough readers, collectors, and stories to become part of local memory.
Old Tampa Book Company did all three.
For years, the shop operated at 507 North Tampa Street in downtown Tampa. It was a used, rare, and out-of-print bookstore, the kind of place where a person browsed through thousands of books without needing a particular title in mind. It was not a large chain store with bright displays and quick turnover. It was a downtown bookshop with older volumes, collectible books, and a local reputation.
Today, the store is closed. That alone gives the story a certain sadness, because independent bookstores do not disappear quietly from the lives of people who loved them. But Old Tampa Book Company also carried something else into Tampa memory: reports of strange happenings, a haunted reputation, and a story about a ghost in a top hat.
That combination makes it a natural entry in any collection of storied bookshops.
A downtown Tampa bookstore
Old Tampa Book Company was located in the heart of Tampa, at 507 North Tampa Street. Descriptions of the shop from earlier visitors and local listings describe it as a used and rare bookshop with roughly 40,000 books. Its inventory included collectible, rare, used, and out-of-print titles, the kind of stock that attracts readers who enjoy looking through shelves rather than searching only by keyword.
The shop had a good reputation among book people. In 2012, Creative Loafing Tampa Bay named it “Best Used, Rare and Out of Print Books,” calling it one of the coolest little shops in downtown Tampa and noting that customers could search the inventory online, though browsing in person was part of the appeal.
That detail matters. Stores like this are not built only around sales. They are built around discovery. A reader might arrive looking for Florida history and leave with an old field guide, a first edition, a forgotten novel, or a stack of paperbacks from the sidewalk sale.
Old Tampa Book Company belonged to the old style of bookshop: narrow, layered, practical, full of inventory, and meant for people willing to take their time.
The Browns and the passing of the store
Before its later ownership, Old Tampa Book Company was associated with Ellen and David Brown, who were described in local coverage as longtime owners and “urban pioneers.” In 2015, the store entered a transition period when Carrie Carnes, who had worked there for years and handled online sales, prepared to take over with her husband, Matt Saxon.
The change in ownership was more than a business transaction. It was a passing of knowledge. A used and rare bookstore depends on more than a cash register and an address. The owner has to know the stock, the regular customers, the buying habits, the online market, and the odd rhythm of a shop where every item is not identical to the next.
Carrie Carnes had already worked inside that system. Local reporting from 2015 described her as someone who knew the store well and was ready to continue it. She and Matt Saxon stepped into a business with tens of thousands of books, a downtown location, and a reputation that had already been formed by years of readers walking through the door.
There is something admirable about that kind of succession. A bookstore can look simple from the outside, but the daily work is detailed and constant. Used books have to be bought, sorted, priced, shelved, listed, sold, shipped, and explained. The shopkeeper has to know when an old book is common, when it is scarce, when it is desirable, and when it is simply interesting enough to keep.
Old Tampa Book Company was one of those places where the work behind the counter mattered as much as the books on display.
A store with a haunted reputation
The ghost stories attached to Old Tampa Book Company should be handled carefully. They are part of the shop’s public story, but they are still folklore, reported experiences, and local legend rather than documented fact.
Several haunted-history and ghost-tour sources connect the building to unusual activity. The most repeated story involves a ghostly figure wearing a top hat. Other accounts mention lights, music, a chandelier, and chairs that seemed to move when no one was present.
In a 2015 Deep South Magazine article, Carrie Carnes was quoted describing incidents where everything had been turned off at night, only for classical music to be playing or a chandelier to be on the next morning. She also said that although she knew the place very well, she did not like being there alone at night.
That is the kind of statement that gives a haunting story more weight than a vague rumor. It does not prove a ghost, of course. It does show that the people who worked there had experiences they found difficult to dismiss.
Other accounts claim the building had once been a tailor shop before becoming a bookstore and that some furniture remained from that earlier business. Later ghost stories connected those older chairs to reports of movement inside the shop. Again, this belongs to the realm of local legend, but it is easy to see why the story stayed attached to the place.
Old buildings often collect stories because many people have used them for many purposes. A downtown building may have been a shop, office, workroom, or storage space long before readers knew it as a bookstore. When a later business fills the rooms with old books, the atmosphere changes. Visitors are more likely to notice noises, shadows, odd reflections, and the normal creaks of an older structure.
Whether one believes in ghosts or not, Old Tampa Book Company had the right ingredients for a haunted bookstore story: an older downtown building, previous uses, antique furniture, dim corners, old books, long business hours, and workers who had been inside after closing.
The strange appeal of haunted bookstores
There is a reason haunted bookstore stories appeal to readers.
A bookstore already deals in the past. Used books have previous owners. Rare books have histories. Out-of-print books have survived changes in taste, publishing, and time. A bookstore that sells older material gives customers a direct encounter with things that have already passed through other hands.
Add a ghost story to that setting, and the place becomes more than a retail shop. It becomes a local mystery.
It doesn’t mean the ghost story has to be accepted literally. The value of the story is also cultural. It shows how people talk about places that seem different from ordinary stores. A grocery store may have history, but people do not usually expect mystery there. A used bookstore almost invites it. The setting already includes paper, dust, names written inside covers, old photographs tucked into books, and titles that may not have been opened for years.
Old Tampa Book Company fit that pattern well.
Its haunted reputation gave people another reason to remember it. A customer might have first gone there for a used book, but later told someone about the ghost stories. A visitor might have heard the top-hat legend first, then stopped in because of curiosity. Either way, the folklore and the bookstore became linked.
The closing
Old Tampa Book Company eventually closed to the public. Some sources report that the shop closed in December 2017 because of an unexplained maintenance issue. Later listings marked it as permanently closed.
For readers who knew the shop, that closing left a gap in Tampa’s book landscape. Downtown areas change quickly. Old storefronts become restaurants, offices, apartments, bars, coffee shops, or empty spaces. A bookstore can vanish from the street faster than its memory vanishes from the people who visited it.
Once they close, the inventory is usually dispersed. The books go to buyers, dealers, storage units, estate sales, online shops, or other stores. A collection that took years to build can be broken apart in a short period of time.
The result is not only the loss of a business. It is the loss of a browsing experience that cannot be reconstructed in the same way.
Why Old Tampa Book Company belongs in Storied Bookshops
Old Tampa Book Company deserves to be remembered because it represents a type of bookstore that has become harder to find: a downtown used and rare bookshop with local ownership, a large inventory, and a distinct reputation.
It also belongs in the category of storied bookshops because the store’s story did not end with its sales records. People wrote about it, visited it, recommended it, photographed it, and repeated its ghost stories. It became part of Tampa’s book culture and part of the city’s haunted folklore.
The most interesting thing about Old Tampa Book Company may be the way its identity rested on both the practical and the mysterious.
On the practical side, it sold books. Thousands of them. Used, rare, collectible, out-of-print, and ordinary books that readers wanted.
On the mysterious side, it became associated with a top-hat ghost, unexplained music, lights, moving furniture, and the uneasiness some people reported after dark.
A truthful account has to make room for both without confusing one for the other.
The facts show that Old Tampa Book Company was a real bookstore at 507 North Tampa Street, known for used and rare books, once praised by local media, later transferred to new ownership, and eventually closed.
The legends show something else: how a bookstore can become part of a city’s imagination.
For a while, Old Tampa Book Company gave downtown Tampa a place where readers could look through old books, collectors could hunt for something specific, and visitors could step into a shop that seemed removed from the speed of the street outside.
Now the shop is gone, but the story remains.
And sometimes, for a bookstore, that is how the last chapter is written.